We have reached the "creme de la creme" of the winners...as a certain actress in this volume famously said in her Best Actress-winning performance.
Making it to the top 20 feels like a long time coming as I originally posted my first two volumes last summer...and it took me until December to finally finish up on volumes 3 and 4.
The following 19 actresses (because one of them won twice) give truly remarkable performances. In fact, the quality of these works are so high that I actually struggled as to how to rank them...and even before posting, I shifted a few performances around and even dropped one by 5 slots.
I guess you can say it has been an unnecessary bloodbath over here.
I will save any further thoughts for the end of the post where I will also be making a special announcement about a new series of posts I hope to do.
_________________________________
#20 - Helen Mirren, The Queen (2006)
When discussing Oscar winners, people do often like to joke that those performances are probably very loud and dramatic. Did the actress scream and wail and break some plates? Then perhaps an Oscar was sent her way!
Leave it to an actress like Dame Helen Mirren to steamroll her way through award season by playing the stoic and sterling Queen Elizabeth II.
Let's just say I have my thoughts about the Monarchy...and I will leave it at that. I will state that I do find them fascinating and as a kid, I was obsessed with Princess Diana.
Her funeral is still so vividly in my mind that when I revisited clips of it online when the 25th anniversary occurred in 2022, I was at how much I still actually recalled despite having not seen it for over two decades.
Considering this movie took place during that time period and focused on the backlash that the royals got for their lack of emotional outreach, it was very much up my alley.
I still think The Queen is a very good movie and I think Mirren does a splendid job playing who was arguably the most famous woman in the world.
Mirren had been one of those actresses who had been worshipped in the UK (much like Judi Dench and now a lot like Olivia Colman) but had not made a true mark on US audiences until she reached middle age. Go back and watch her as Jane Tennyson on the Prime Suspect anthology series and you will see some truly wonderful work there...or her work opposite Nigel Hawthorne in The Madness of King George.
She did face very stiff competition from Judi Dench in Notes on a Scandal and Penelope Cruz in Volver, but I do feel like this was a great example of how much quiet dignity can be powerful onscreen. The stillness she often portrayed was just as strong as any actress who might've screamed and thrown a plate to the floor.
_________________________________
#19 - Emma Thompson, Howards End (1992)
Much like Helen Mirren, you also have another great bawdy dame playing at a level of stillness.
This would be Emma Thompson in Howards End, a performance of such restraint and quiet nobility that still managed to win the hearts of nearly every major voting body that year even though she wasn't throwing around any plates and screaming to anyone who would listen.
Subtle performances often do lead to debate, because for every person who may love it, another will say they did absolutely nothing. I think in the case of Emma Thompson, however, many often consider her win to be richly deserved.
1992 was also a bizarre year for women at the Oscars because both of Lead and Supporting were taken up by non-American actresses except one in each: Susan Sarandon in Lead and, infamously, Marisa Tomei in Supporting.
Some claimed that part of the reason Tomei won in Supporting was because she was the only American...which doesn't explain why Sarandon didn't win...even though Roger Ebert predicted that would be the reason.
As a sidebar, Tomei's race was far more divided as the Globes went for Joan Plowright and the critics were more inclined to vote for Judy Davis...and then you have Miranda Richardson who was up for Damage as opposed to her more high profile work in The Crying Game.
Thompson was basically winning every Best Actress award under the sun for Howards End and she deserved to...so yes, subtlety wins the day and the great love affair that we Americans have had for Emma Thompson began here.
___________________________________
#18 - Jodie Foster, The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
Just three years after her first win for The Accused, Jodie Foster came back with what might be the defining role of her career: Clarice Starling.
Just as Emma Thompson would achieve the following year, Foster's Starling is a very subdued performance with a lot of internal anguish.
A lot of what has made The Silence of the Lambs an iconic film are the scenes between Foster and Anthony Hopkins, often filmed in the traditional Jonathan Demme extreme close-up form.
Hopkins was only onscreen for roughly 20 minutes and made such a strong impression that I honestly didn't realize for years how brief his screen time was...but a big reason that those scenes work so well are due to Foster. Hopkins is obviously creating an iconic character here, but the pained turmoil that Foster gives in return manages to make the most chilling of scenes have a strong emotional core.
Despite her very well deserved win, I do want to mention some of her fellow nominees which included a very iconic duo: Geena Davis & Susan Sarandon as Thelma & Louise and also the very sensual turn by Laura Dern in Rambling Rose. I think had it not been for Foster, this would've been an easy win for Sarandon.
___________________________________
#17 - Kathy Bates, Misery (1990)
It just dawned on me that in the span of just 3 slots, I put the three women who won the Oscar between 1990-1992. It was a damn good stretch!
Of the three women, it seemed like Kathy Bates was the only one that didn't seem like a lock on Oscar night. She had some stiff competition and they were for performances in more typical Oscar caliber films.
Bates, at the time, was not a super well-known actress. She was primarily known in the NY Theatre scene having starred in the original productions of Marsha Norman's 'night Mother and Terrence McNally's Frankie & Johnny in the Clair de Lune.
When it came time for director Rob Reiner and screenwriter William Goldman to discuss casting, both seemed in agreement that despite not being a big star, Kathy Bates would be the right choice to play the freakish and psychotic Annie Wilkes, one of the more memorable human villains from the Stephen King canon.
As I stated above, it didn't seem like Bates was a sure thing on Oscar night. Her competition was quite fierce as critical favorites Anjelica Huston and Joanne Woodward were up for The Grifters and Mr. & Mrs. Bridge respectively...and to further add to that, Julia Roberts was up for her star making vehicle Pretty Woman....and while she didn't have a shot, it doesn't hurt that Meryl Streep was the fifth nominee for Postcards from the Edge.
I think on paper, Huston seemed like the logical choice because her film came the closest to a Best Picture nomination and due to her pedigree at the time, lots of publications felt she deserved to have a Lead Oscar.
Bates being in a horror film seemed like a detriment, but...she pulled it off...and DESERVEDLY SO!
What a wonderful win this was! Bates truly nailed this part and it is simply one of those roles where I can't imagine what other actresses would've done with it. In lesser hands, I think it easily would have been a train wreck of epic proportions.
This was a great way for Bates to start off her career (in terms of being a household name), and almost instantly, she seemed to develop widespread acclaim and admiration.
________________________________
#16 - Diane Keaton, Annie Hall (1977)
Despite everything that seems to go on with Woody Allen, Diane Keaton always stands by him. Even after their relationship failed, she would be there for him.
There is no denying that Keaton's presence in many of Allen's films was a truly wonderful and welcoming feature. It also helped provide a great dichotomy between her comedic work with Allen and the more dramatic fare in The Godfather films or the truly bleak Looking for Mr. Goodbar.
When watching Annie Hall, you get the sense that Allen knew exactly what it would take to make the world fall in love even more with Diane Keaton than it already had.
As the titular character, Keaton is simply sublime.
It is a cliche to say, but there is a reason why Annie Hall is often considered to be the quintessential film Woody Allen movie: he is arguably at his best playing (essentially) himself, but he goes toe-to-toe with Keaton, who can be right at his level and he gives her nothing but gold to work with.
Upon a recent rewatch while on COVID quarantine in 2020, I marveled at how well the movie held up and how truly wonderful those two were together.
But I could ramble on about Keaton forever so I will just leave it at that...oh well..."la dee da, la dee da, la, la, yeah..."
________________________________
#15 - Sally Field, Norma Rae (1979)
When most people think about Sally Field these days, they do think of her as a serious actress who is also very adept at comedy, as well.
#14 - Anna Magnani, The Rose Tattoo (1955)
#13 - Faye Dunaway, Network (1976)
#12 - Sissy Spacek, Coal Miner's Daughter (1980)
Every year as of late, I feel like it is the same thing:
Which legendary musical icon is getting a biopic?
In the last few years, we have gotten Freddie Mercury/Queen, Elton John, Judy Garland, Whitney Houston, and Elvis...and it has been a bit tiring.
If you want a real blueprint on a truly epic musical biopic performance, look no further than that of Sissy Spacek as Loretta Lynn in Coal Miner's Daughter.
The legend goes that Loretta Lynn had zero knowledge of Spacek when she insisted she play her. All she saw was Spacek's headshot and said "That is who I want".
Spacek was considered something of a quirky and offbeat "It" girl of the 1970s having acted in many weird low-budget indie films like Badlands or more surreal projects like 3 Women or a horror drama like Carrie.
She may have broken tradition by getting an Oscar nom for Carrie, but she still didn't seem like the kind of actress who would dive into a more traditional kind of film.
The results were glorious, to put it mildly. Not only does she manage to play Lynn convincingly from AGE THIRTEEN up into her 30s, but she does her own singing and nails all of Lynn's mannerisms.
Even though she had truly intense competition from the likes of Mary Tyler Moore in Ordinary People, I think this was one of the best selections ever made in this category and certainly would've gotten my vote.
_______________________________
#11 - Olivia Colman, The Favourite (2018)
At the 2019 Oscars, it was expected that it would be the long overdue coronation for Glenn Close, who had still yet to win an Oscar despite now having 7 nominations.
The narrative was so strong that many seemed to ignore that Olivia Colman did pick up some solid precursors that did show some strong support...not to mention the fact she was leading the anonymous Oscar Ballot Polls that come out before every ceremony (though that is not always the best barometer as that same year, Richard E. Grant led those same polls for Supporting Actor).
Plus, Glenn Close was the sole nominee for The Wife while Colman was in The Favourite, a movie with 10 nominations (tied for the most of the evening). While not always the case, it certainly showed that more people were prone to watch The Favourite and, perhaps, skip The Wife.
I will state right now that if Close had won, it wouldn't have been a horrible win...but Close should already have 2-3 Oscars on her mantle for significantly better work. As we all know with the Oscars, it just doesn't tend to happen that way.
Olivia Colman was the right choice here. While you could debate she was certainly borderline supporting, I am perfectly fine with her being in Lead. It certainly makes more sense than her co-star Emma Stone being in Supporting as she is CLEARLY the real lead of the film.
Colman having this moment was glorious and after having wowed me on shows like Broadchurch or her heartbreaking performance in the film Tyrannosaur, I was ready to see this Colman surge happen.
I feel like as of this writing, there does seem to be a bit of Colman fatigue in the air, but I do think she will rebound and come back to win another potential Oscar.
Her Queen Anne is such a diabolical character, and she truly redefined how remarkable a tragicomic acting style can be.
_________________________________
#10 - Cate Blanchett, Blue Jasmine (2013)
I often debate to myself who gave the best performance in a Woody Allen movie. After a while, you can only take so much of the "Woody Allen character" persona that he puts on and aside from Diane Keaton in Annie Hall, I feel like a lot of the best performances by females came in the supporting arena, like Judy Davis in Husbands & Wives or Dianne Wiest in Bullets over Broadway.
Despite the film essentially being A Streetcar Named Desire meets the Bernie Madoff scandal, I think Blue Jasmine was a very solid film that provided a truly magnificent role for Cate Blanchett to play...and I will state the claim now that I think this is the best performance in a Woody Allen movie and, not surprisingly, I think it is one of the best performances to ever win an Oscar.
The anxious, cold, neurotic energy she gives Jasmine is simply so compelling and it feels, at times, very reminiscent to Geraldine Page's Eve from Interiors. Both actresses are simply fantastic at making these somewhat frustrating people truly compelling.
I often state that Cate Blanchett is the greatest actress working today, at least in the English language...and this year, she may very well win a 3rd Oscar, which will put her in the same league as other three-time winners like Ingrid Bergman and Meryl Streep.
If Blanchett does win for Tar, I would be inclined to place her in my top 20 for that performance as well.
She's just THAT good.
_______________________________
#9 - Sophia Loren, Two Women (1961)
#8 - Vivien Leigh, Gone with the Wind (1939)
While other dames like Helen Mirren and Judi Dench would become more celebrated in the US as they got older, Maggie Smith made her mark while she was in her 30s.
While known mostly these as the Dowager Countess on Downton Abbey and Professor McGonagall in the Harry Potter series, I first discovered Smith as the Mother Superior in Sister Act...and I can recall my mom saying that Smith was such a good actress and that growing up, she was considered one of the greatest.
When you look at her work in a movie like The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie, you can clearly see why.
As the titular Brodie, Smith is truly remarkable at playing such a truly chaotic free spirit who seems to challenge her students and any kind of authority.
She is a woman on a mission, and we hear it often: "Little girls, I am in the business of putting old heads on young shoulders, and all my pupils are the creme de la creme. Give me a girl at an impressionable age and she is mine for life".
Even typing it out, I could CLEARLY hear it in my head.
Her voice and how she uses it is simply like some sort of unique and priceless instrument.
If you want to see a great example, check out the final scene she shares with Pamela Franklin. Both are splendid in the scene, but just watch how Smith handles everything being thrown in her face as to how her actions led to some truly horrendous consequences...AND how well she modulates her voice.
_____________________________________________________
#6 - Marion Cotillard, La Vie en Rose (2007)
If I were to pick an Oscar win by a performer that truly caused such immense joy for me when their name was called, I think the top of that list would be Marion Cotillard.
Going into the Oscars, there was certainly an expectation that Cotillard could overtake Julie Christie as the winner after her win at BAFTA (Julie Christie's home turf) showed a surge of last-minute surge of support for her.
The biggest hurdle for Cotillard was that her movie was not widely seen in terms of box office, and it was a foreign film.
While a movie like Parasite finally winning Best Picture and the win by Youn Yuh-jung for Minari show that the tides could change some for the better, it still seems like performances in a foreign language have a significant hurdle to overcome.
Even in the case of Parasite, none of the performers from it gained major traction for an Oscar nomination, which is truly a disgrace when you see who actually WON Oscars in most of the acting categories that year.
Cotillard's win makes sense on paper for its transformative nature and its volcanic emotional toll, but it does feel like a random outlier still due to the fact it was a performance in French...and only one of 6 performers to win an Oscar for a predominantly non-English role.
As I discussed with Sophia Loren, I think the glamour angle did help a lot with Cotillard too...because it does seem like this category in recent years does lean towards ingenues more often than to actresses of a certain age.
That isn't to discount Cotillard, of course, because the performance is more than worthy to be praised from now and until the cows come home.
________________________________
#5 - Vivien Leigh, A Streetcar Named Desire (1951)
#4 - Charlize Theron, Monster (2003)
#3 - Meryl Streep, Sophie's Choice (1982)
_______________________________
#2 - Katharine Hepburn, The Lion in Winter (1968)
#1 - Elizabeth Taylor, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (1966)
No comments:
Post a Comment