Saturday, January 28, 2023

My Review of Lila Neugebauer's CAUSEWAY

Sometimes, you shouldn't sleep on a movie.

This time of year, there is so much talk about the lead up to the Oscars that certain movies end up dominating the conversation at the expense of others that don't end up gaining traction with the industry.

My knowledge of Causeway was originally hearing about it under its original title Red, White, & Water. It seemed like one of those quiet low-budget indies that could end up becoming an Oscar contender...especially with Jennifer Lawrence attached to it.

COVID did delay its release and it eventually premiered on Apple TV+ just as last year's (ugh...) Best Picture winner Coda did. 

Causeway did get good reviews, particularly for Brian Tyree Henry...but it did just seem to sort of slip away in terms of having a higher profile.

I just didn't really think of giving it a try, but then I kept hearing more and more about the work of Jennifer Lawrence and Brian Tyree Henry...only for the latter to get a last-minute surge from behind to get a Supporting Actor Oscar nomination.

A friend of mine ended up watching the film and his reaction to the film made me realize I should give it a try, especially due to its relatively brisk running time of just over 90 minutes.

Causeway is the film debut of Lila Neugebauer, who had made a name for herself in the theater world for directing such acclaimed productions as The Waverly Gallery and Mary Page Marlowe along with directing episodes of shows such as Maid and The Sex Lives of College Girls.

I wouldn't say this is a film that breaks any new ground in terms of its visuals or the styles/aesthetics, but Neugebauer managed to take a script by novelist Ottessa Moshfegh and Elizabeth Sanders & Luke Goebel and she created a truly nice dual character piece.

I don't think Causeway is necessarily a remarkable film, but somehow, Lawrence and Henry manage to make it something special.

Lawrence plays Lynsey, a soldier who is deployed from Afghanistan after receiving a traumatic brain energy. After a rehabilitation period, she returns home to New Orleans where she stays with her mother anxiously awaiting a chance for redeployment. 

She ends up connecting with James Aucoin (Henry), a mechanic with whom she is sort of connected for having known his younger sister in school. The two hang out frequently and she discovers James is going through his own physical and emotional trauma as he ended up causing the death of his young nephew in a car crash on the Lake Pontchartrain Causeway.

When I think of Jennifer Lawrence, I remember how she seemed to just wow everybody with her "wise beyond her years" performance in Winter's Bone. Then, she managed to just be thrust into superstardom when she became Katniss in The Hunger Games films and then, sadly, she got sucked into the orbit of David O. Russell which led to her playing characters who were probably too mature for her to play...and yet, she won an Oscar for one and got nominations for two others.

It also didn't help that she was a major figure in the orbit of an even more problematic figure: Harvey Weinstein. 

With her turn in 2021's Don't Look Up, she managed to provide one of that film's better performances but her being a part of this quiet indie playing such an emotionally subdued role could not have come at a better time.

I almost feel like we should all sing a round of Hello, Dolly and change it to Jenny, because it was an absolute joy to see Jennifer Lawrence back to doing work like this. If it hadn't been such a strong year for women in film, I think we might've seen her get more traction in the Actress race...then again...Michelle Williams got nominated and I think Lawrence was far more compelling.

Brian Tyree Henry just came off a run as Paper Boi on the brilliant Atlanta, and what a way for him to get a nice boost into what should hopefully be a truly eclectic career that will take him down a path similar to his other Atlanta co-star Lakeith Stanfield. 

Henry has such a lovable and charming and gruff presence that you can't help but just anxiously await every time he comes onscreen. His vulnerability and his authenticity levels are simply off the charts. It was such a real and lived in performance and I am glad that Academy voters were smart enough to vote for him even though they were apparently too busy to vote for Danielle Deadwyler....

..........that snub will take a while to recover from......

On another note, due to Neugebauer's theater background, it was nice to see a small ensemble of actors who are primarily stage performers like Linda Emond playing Lynsey's mother, Jayne Houdyshell playing Lynsey's nurse, Stephen McKinley Henderson as Lynsey's doctor, and Russell Harvard as her brother. While all of these are very small performances, they all do lovely work.

Causeway is a small movie, and it is a bit slow and plodding despite its 95-minute runtime, but it is truly a bittersweet delight to watch Jennifer Lawrence and Brian Tyree Henry come together with such a tender chemistry that felt very palpable. 

Considering how I have been so disappointed with many movies this year, I am willing to give this one a bit of a boost thanks to how compelling the relationship arc was to watch.

RATING: ****1/2 out of *****

Tuesday, January 24, 2023

ONE HORRID SNUB SORT OF SPOILS THE BUNCH : My Reactions to the Nominations for the 95th Annual Academy Awards

 For the last few years, even dating back to my old blog, I always posted my final predictions for who/what I suspected to get an Academy Award/Oscar nomination.

This year, I have been relatively disengaged from this process. I have been following it to some degree but my passion for a lot of the films in consideration is not as strong. This is a significant blow because I was mostly so disappointed with 2021 that I was hoping for a better 2022...and sadly, I think 2022 might be worse.

I will comment on these nominations and point out any interesting statistics...and in addition to that, I will comment on any major snubs or surprises or frustrating inclusions.

So, here are the big 8 categories:

________________________________________________

BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY:

All Quiet on the Western Front

Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery

Living

Top Gun: Maverick

Women Talking 

THOUGHTS: Despite the fact that I enjoyed Top Gun: Maverick, I am bit unsure if I feel its Screenplay deserves an Oscar nod...which is a slot that a lot of people predicted would go to The Whale.

As it stands, I think that Women Talking might manage to eek out a win here. It seemed like such a sure thing early on, but its award season trajectory has been such a misfire.

I feel like, as of this moment, it has the best shot to still take this...and its corresponding BP nod does help as no film has won an Adapted Screenplay Oscar with a BP nod since Gods & Monsters in 1999.

________________________________________

BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY:

The Banshees of Inisherin

Everything Everywhere All at Once

The Fablemans

Tar 

Triangle of Sadness

THOUGHTS: These five slots seemed to be what were predicted by nearly everybody...though I feel like some hoped that Charlotte Wells would slip in for Aftersun.

This race is going to come down to The Banshees of Inisherin and Everything Everywhere All at Once...and I truly feel like it can go either way.

Both of them are frontrunners for Best Picture, although the latter has the major advantage right now. I personally hope that they will use this category as a means to honor McDonagh as I am sort of suspecting that The Daniels will take Director.

_________________________________________

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR:

Brendan Gleeson, The Banshees of Inisherin

Brian Tyree Henry, Causeway

Judd Hirsch, The Fablemans

Barry Keoghan, The Banshees of Inisherin

Ke Huy Kuan, Everything Everywhere All at Once

THOUGHTS: I will have to admit that I have not seen Causeway yet, but I have been very familiar with the praise and acclaim that Henry has been getting for this performance.

Many have been bemoaning that he was missing out in favor of contenders like Eddie Redmayne, but he managed to pull through here.

The nomination of Judd Hirsch is interesting. Earlier in the season, it seemed like he and his co-star Paul Dano would both be nominated and then it seemed like Dano had the edge.

In some ways, it feels a little like Belfast last year where Catriona Balfe got nominated everywhere and then got snubbed while they nominated legend Judi Dench for her much smaller performance.

However, unlike Dench, I really liked Hirsch's brief performance and while I doubt he'd make my personal lineup, I do like seeing him here. His scene was one of the better things about The Fablemans.

Frankly, even though he is a borderline lead, Kuan is winning this and I am okay with it...although if I am being honest, I would be happy with one of the Banshees men winning...particularly Keoghan. 

_________________________________________

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS:

Angela Bassett, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever

Hong Chau, The Whale

Kerry Condon, The Banshees of Inisherin

Jamie Lee Curtis, Everything Everywhere All at Once

Stephanie Hsu, Everything Everywhere All at Once

THOUGHTS: We will see what SAG and BAFTA bring us but as of now, I sort of think that Bassett will take SAG and the Oscar but Condon will take BAFTA leaving some slight suspicion beforehand.

Bassett not having an Oscar seems like a crime. She should've won in 1994 for What's Love Got To Do With It? and the fact that it was the only nomination she has received until today is another crime.

It also seems sad that she will win a "career Oscar" for a solid but not amazing performance in a Marvel movie...but I will just try my best to close my eyes and pretend it is for something better like when Laura Dern won for Marriage Story...though Bassett's win would be more deserved than that one.

As much as FilmTwitter loves to bash her, I am very happy for Curtis to receive this long overdue nomination. She should have at least two for Trading Places and True Lies and maybe even a third for A Fish Called Wanda. I did love the energy she brought to this role, plus her scenes in which she played the Hot-Dog fingered lover of Michelle Yeoh were a lot of fun.

Hsu getting in will make a lot of people happy, but maybe the fact that I was not as over the moon with the film makes me less enthused with her. I just didn't find her to be that remarkable, nor did she make me care much about her character even though I knew I was supposed to.

I still think Kerry Condon deserves this and while she was the critical favorite, it seems like the televised awards are turning their attention to Bassett. 

_________________________________________

BEST ACTOR:

Austin Butler, Elvis

Colin Farrell, The Banshees of Inisherin

Brendan Fraser, The Whale

Paul Mescal, Aftersun

Bill Nighy, Living

THOUGHTS: Nothing really shocking here. Some thought that Mescal was vulnerable, and he sort of was...but I think he made a solid case even though Aftersun was not gaining traction in other categories.

Nighy was expected, but I can't really comment on him as I have not seen his movie yet. All I know is that it is an English-language adaptation of Kurosawa's Ikiru.

At this point, you can really call it a three-horse race. 

I'd say it is Farrell vs. Fraser with Butler as a strong dark horse. A lot of it depends on how things go at SAG and BAFTA...but if I were to predict now, I would say SAG goes to Fraser while Farrell gets the BAFTA...and if that is true, I really truly think you could make a strong case for either.

Since Banshees is more of a BP heavyweight, it could tip things into Farrell's favor, but I also think Fraser has the better narrative.

Butler, on the other hand, fits the overblown typical narrative of a biopic performance that Oscar voters normally love...and if I am being honest, he is far better than Rami Malek was in Bohemian Rhapsody.

I do like how this one is a little bit of a race at the moment, so that is rather exciting.

_________________________________________

BEST ACTRESS:

Cate Blanchett, Tar

Ana de Armas, Blonde

Andrea Riseborough, To Leslie

Michelle Williams, The Fabelmans

Michelle Yeoh, Everything Everywhere All at Once

THOUGHTS: Despite the mostly strong lineup we have here, I am rather upset.

The fact that they snubbed Danielle Deadwyler for her work in Till is truly a shame. I would even go as far to call it one of the worst snubs I have ever seen for a performance during my lifetime.

And this wasn't a case of someone being a longshot...she managed to get CC, SAG, and BAFTA nods and while not necessarily a lock, I feel like most people felt comfortable enough that she would make it in. 

Then you have Michelle Williams.

Earlier in the season, many suspected that not only would she campaign and be nominated for Supporting Actress, a lot of the buzz was that she would finally win an Oscar. Things changed when she suddenly got promoted to Lead and it seemed as though she might even get snubbed.

That only seemed to become more of a reality because she got snubbed by both SAG and BAFTA which was very crucial as those are arguably the two most important precursors which represent the actual industry.

Perhaps the most fascinating inclusion in this race is Riseborough, but honestly, I sort of expected it...or at the very least, I am not super shocked.

In the last few weeks, many celebrities via Twitter began praising Riseborough's work in the little-seen To Leslie and felt it was a performance that everyone needed to see...and the grass-roots effort seemed to surge from there. 

I do have access to a copy of To Leslie and I intend to watch it this weekend, but of the clips I have seen, Riseborough does seem to be giving it her all. There have been comparisons to her work mirroring that of Gena Rowlands, particularly in A Woman Under the Influence.

 I am going to say that if her performance comes anywhere near close to THAT, she should be winning in a landslide.

As it stands, the race does seem to be leaning in Blanchett's favor and it would be her second Best Actress win and third win overall.

Would that be a deserved win? Overall yes. I actually do prefer her to Yeoh, but I sort of like the idea of Yeoh sweeping in for the victory. It would be a career win and also for a good performance.

Then you have Ana de Armas, and while I do not like Blonde as a film much at all, she truly was compelling in it. I still think Williams is the real culprit that should be bumped in favor of putting in Deadwyler, but I do think the inclusion of Riseborough (a very wonderful and underrated actress) is an exciting change of pace as these out-of-nowhere (of sorts) nominations could become more of a reality rather than the repetitive cult nature of nominating the same performances as other voting bodies. 

I think I will do an additional separate post that will go more in depth regarding the Andrea Riseborough push and the controversy it is starting to cause online.

Be on the look out for that soon!

_________________________________________

BEST DIRECTOR:

Martin McDonagh, The Banshees of Inisherin

Daniel Kwan, Daniel Schienert, Everything Everywhere All at Once

Steven Spielberg, The Fabelmans

Todd Field, Tar

Ruben Ostlund, Triangle of Sadness

THOUGHTS:

I guess you could say the "surprise" here is Ruben Ostlund, although he certainly seemed plausible consider the support his film was getting along with the fact the Academy does like to honor one artsy/indie/foreign director each year. I sort of thought it would be Edward Berger after the massive surge that All Quiet on the Western Front received, but I suppose Ostlund is not surprising in the grand scheme. I originally thought Park Chan-wook would be that candidate, but after his film didn't gain much traction (AND got snubbed in International Feature today), it seemed like more of a longshot.

I do think we are going to be looking at a victory for The Daniels here...unless the DGA throws a curveball and gives it to Spielberg. Granted, Spielberg was snubbed at BAFTA so it could still go to The Daniels even in that scenario.

I suspect that if it isn't The Daniels, it'll be Spielberg in a boost of sentimental support.

It does seem like the quick surge that Avatar received faded fast and lost momentum for James Cameron, who originally seemed like a fairly sure bet. I personally couldn't care less, but I am just being snobbish there.

No women this year after we had two years in a row of women winning...and sadly, Sarah Polley never gained traction for Women Talking. Hopefully, justice will be served for her in Adapted Screenplay.

_________________________________________

BEST PICTURE:

All Quiet on the Western Front

Avatar: The Way of Water

The Banshees of Inisherin

Everything Everywhere All at Once

Elvis

The Fabelmans

Tar

Top Gun: Maverick

Triangle of Sadness

Women Talking

THOUGHTS: No major surprises here.

I would say if any of them falls under that category, it would've been Triangle of Sadness but it didn't seem implausible.

Women Talking was on the brink, but since I am still holding out hope that it'll be a clear winner in Adapted Screenplay, I figured it would make it in for the 10th slot.

I think the one film that seemed to have a chance to slip in here was Babylon, but for some reason, I just felt like that wasn't going to happen after how majorly it bombed at the box office and its critical response was a little less than passionate. 

As it stands right now, I feel like the clear frontrunner is Everything Everywhere All at Once. I just...I am glad to see such an unconventional movie have this kind of traction for awards, but by the same token, I just didn't have much of a connection to the film.

I admired certain aspects of it, particularly its cast, but I just did not find it to be the amazing film that many seemed to make it out to be.

I do think the runner-up would have to be The Banshees of Inisherin...but could it actually still take the top prize?

I would say it is possible, but that could be because I have a bit of a bias as I actually DID REALLY REALLY LIKE Banshees. A lot of it is going to come down to how the guilds vote but I feel like both it and EEAAO could do well on a preferential ballot system.

_________________________________________

FINAL THOUGHTS:

I will say it again.....

DANIELLE. DEADWYLER.

What a horrible and unforgivable snub.

The sad truth is that she was never going to win, but I really didn't think she would actually get snubbed.

And on top of that, they also snubbed Viola Davis for The Women King, who managed to get in at every major precursor she needed. Had Davis made it in, it would've been her FIFTH nomination which would've given her more nominations than any other African American actress...or any other female POC.

I do know Davis will be back...and I think Deadwyler could still nab a great role...but it still seems like a true disgrace that they missed out.

The Andrea Riseborough nomination is going to get a lot of press, especially in relation to those snubs, but I will save more of my thoughts on that for another post that I hope to have up sometime in the next couple of days.

In the grand scheme of things, they made some interesting and inspired choices with some of the acting nominations...but a lot of that gets dampened by the Danielle Deadwyler snub.

Sunday, January 22, 2023

My Ranking of the 95 Best Actress Oscar Winners: Vol. 4 (40 -21)

We are inching ever closer to my top 20.

In this volume, I think you can see that I shift more towards a sense of reverence in how I feel about many of these performances...especially as we reach the 20s.

Let's get into the list and I will leave the rest of my thoughts for the end.

_____________________________________________

#40 - Holly Hunter, The Piano (1993) 

I feel like Holly Hunter's win for The Piano has aged rather well for myself and a lot of other critics...but I am still not entirely sure she should've won. I am more inclined to think that Angela Bassett should've won for her truly iconic turn as Tina Turner in What's Love Got to Do With It? or Stockard Channing for duplicating her stage performance of Ouisa in John Guare's Six Degrees of Separation.

Much like Hunter's performance, I have also grown more fond of The Piano as I found it to be an obtuse bore when I saw it as a teenager. I consider it to be a truly haunting film these days and feel that Jane Campion's work on it was truly masterful.

Hunter doesn't speak in the film aside from narration...so the performance relies solely on her expressions. I feel like she does manage to succeed with what she is handed, but I often found myself more drawn to her younger co-star Anna Paquin (Oscar winner at 11 years old) who had such a fascinating screen presence and would often steal scenes.

It is nice to see Hunter getting an Oscar though, especially after losing for her magnificent breakout performance in Broadcast News 6 years earlier.

__________________________________

#39 - Ellen Burstyn, Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore (1974)

Ellen Burstyn is another example of an actress who deserves an Oscar on her mantle and she managed to get it for a good performance...though not her best...and not the best in her category.

Burstyn managed to rebuild her legacy with younger moviegoers with her role as Sara Goldfarb in Requiem for a Dream, which might be the best performance of her career. 

Her role of Alice mostly seems overshadowed these days by the fact that this story would be adapted into a sitcom starring Linda Lavin. 

Not to mention that this is the infamous year in which Ingmar Bergman's Scenes from a Marriage was deemed ineligible for the Oscars as it had originally been a miniseries in Sweden...which meant Liv Ullman couldn't compete. 

Even without Ullman, this category still had an actress giving one of the greatest performances EVER captured on film: Gena Rowlands in A Woman Under the Influence. 

Trying to put aside my massive admiration for the snubbed Ullman and the ferociously brilliant Rowlands, I can commend Burstyn's work here as being feisty and memorable...and hey, ranking her at #37 is certainly nothing to scoff at. 

It is a vibrant performance and I think had the film come out the following year, she would've been an easy sweeper.

_________________________________

#38 - Barbra Streisand, Funny Girl (1968)

Streisand's win is simply due to the fact that she, more than likely, voted for herself.

Despite Funny Girl being her feature film debut and Academy protocols normally stating otherwise, the Academy President and Oscar winner Gregory Peck had pushed strongly (and honestly wisely) for new changes in Academy membership...especially in favor of fresh new blood.

With this in place, we managed to get our first and so far ONLY legit tie in an acting race (the 1931 Best Actor race was not a true tie). 

Streisand tied with Katharine Hepburn in The Lion in Winter (spoiler alert: you won't see her til the next and final volume), who had just won the year before for Guess Who's Coming to Dinner? and now had 3 Oscars.

One of the things that greatly bothers me about Streisand in this film is something that Streisand herself has called out...and that is, I find her often to be a lot less engaged during songs when she is being made to lip-sync.

The vocal performance is obviously stellar, but the visual performance often feels disconnected...and THANKFULLY, she knew this so well that she insisted to William Wyler that first portion of "My Man" be done live and have that blend into a pre-recorded performance. 

The results of the lip-sync in that particular case are marginally more successful with the emotion already set in place...but even then, it does slip for me slightly.

It is a performance that is hurt mostly by filming conventions, but whenever she does overcome it, she is truly exceptional.

___________________________________

#37 - Julianne Moore, Still Alice (2015)


This win for Julianne Moore is another key example of an actress finally winning an overdue Oscar that should've already happened...and in her case, if we are strictly basing it off the actual Oscar nominations, she would've won in 1998 for Boogie Nights and in 2003 for Far From Heaven.

Is this an undeserved win? 

No. 

I would say that her performance in this is handled with a lot of care and is highly emotional. I do think the film around her isn't exactly as strong, which can often work against some performers.

I might've been more inclined to vote for Marion Cotillard in Two Days, One Night, but I think Moore winning for such a devastating and heartbreaking performance is a solid choice, to say the least.

____________________________________

#36 - Jessica Chastain, The Eyes of Tammy Faye (2021)

We are quickly approaching awards season as I write this post, but as of this exact moment, Chastain is our most recent winner...and it is a win that both baffles me and makes me happy.

Last season's Best Actress race was all over the map. For a while, it seemed like Kristen Stewart was on track to win for her work as Princess Diana in Spencer, despite how divided many were on her and the quality of the film.

Then, when she managed to lose the Golden Globe and got snubbed at both SAG and BAFTA, it more or less erased her chances.

While this was all going on, Lady Gaga was doing the rounds to promote House of Gucci and making it known that she took a lot of method classes to the point where it just became a joke. Briefly, it seemed as though she was going to be the frontrunner when she was the only main contender to get nominated at every major precursor...only for her to get snubbed at the Oscars.

Quietly and stealthily, Jessica Chastain crept through the season despite the fact her film was a bomb and got middling reviews. She managed to win the SAG along with the Critic's Choice Award (which simply seemed like them doing their usual copycat routine because if they really were to represent the critics, then Stewart would've won there).

Chastain's performance got mocked by some as being hammy and brash.

Ummm....have people totally forgotten what Tammy Faye-Bakker-Messner was like as a person?

She was loud, she was emotional, she was passionate, and she wore lots of eye makeup and bronzer.

Sure, lily-white Chastain may have been buried under a ton of makeup and fits the bill of a cliche Oscar winner from a biopic but despite the film's sluggish quality, I think she did a very good job at capturing the spirt of this truly interesting woman.

It also doesn't hurt that Chastain is an actress who was truly overdue for this kind of recognition, so her having an Oscar does make everything seem right.

Of the nominees, I might've been inclined to vote for Penelope Cruz for Parallel Mothers.

Of the snubbed contenders, we have a few women who were far more worthy than most of the nominees:

Renate Reinsve, The Worst Person in the World

Tessa Thompson, Passing

Anamarie Vortolomei, Happening

Martha Plimpton, Mass

Tilda Swinton, Memoria

______________________________________

#35 - Glenda Jackson, Women in Love (1970)


I placed Glenda Jackson's second win in my second volume at the rather low ranking of 69. I didn't say much about my opinions of Jackson as an actress at that time, but that was mainly because I wanted to save my thoughts for this moment.

I find Glenda Jackson to be, despite these two Oscar wins, one of the more underrated actresses to come out of the British Renaissance of the 60s and 70s which included contemporaries like the Grande Dames of Julie Christie, Julie Andrews, Judi Dench, Maggie Smith, Eileen Atkins, Helen Mirren, and Diana Rigg.

I actually see a lot of current British darling Olivia Colman in Jackson, but Jackson is her own unique being. The deep and vibrant timbre in her voice in which she can shake the rafters or chill you in the quiet moments is one of my favorites to ever grace a film.

Her political work, including her LEGENDARY takedown of Margaret Thatcher on the Parliament floor the day she passed, is truly honorable as well.

I think her work in Women in Love is fantastic, and her surreal energy matches up perfectly with the film itself...and if you've seen Women in Love...I think you already know that it is quite the trip...

_____________________________________________

#34 - Shirley Booth, Come Back Little Sheba (1952)


In a decade that was dominated by the glamorous Marilyn Monroe, Audrey Hepburn, and Grace Kelly, the Academy managed to honor some truly remarkable character actresses with Best Actress honors. 

I will be talking about one of those in my final volume, but there is a certain joy in seeing a great character actress from the stage like Shirley Booth make her film debut in Come Back, Little Sheba and take a well-deserved Oscar.

Of course, Booth's film career didn't exactly take off and following her win, she seems most remembered for playing the titular maid on the sitcom Hazel. 

Come Back, Little Sheba is a movie that is melodramatic to its detriment; the kind of movie that makes me roll my eyes when I think about the supposed Golden Age of Hollywood.

However, for what it is, I find it to be rather enjoyable and I think Booth manages to sell the material very well...even if the script makes her say "daddy" far too often to the point it almost seems comical.

Booth deserves to be talked about more as a performer, and I think in many ways, what she brought to the table could be seen as being a little ahead of its time. 
__________________________________________

#33 - Louise Fletcher, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (1975)


When Louise Fletcher graced the stage of the Dorothy Chandler Pavillon, it felt a bit like divine justice. 

After her falling out with director Robert Altman, Fletcher left the movie Nashville and the role of Linnea Reese, which had been created just for her. Even after Lily Tomlin took the role, they kept the ASL/Deaf children angle, which was closely linked to her own life as Fletcher was a CODA (Child of Deaf Adults).

Fletcher's acceptance speech also included her performing ASL to her parents (although the camera takes far too long to zoom out to show what she is saying), which makes for an emotional and important moment.

1975 was a year which still stands out as being rather weak for strong female roles. Fletcher did benefit strongly from this as she is a case of someone who probably belonged in Supporting.

I do think her fellow nominee Isabel Adjani truthfully may have been the right choice for her work in The Story of Adele H. but you can't deny the iconic power of Fletcher as Nurse Ratched.

As an actress, I feel like Fletcher was never able to escape Ratched's shadow sort of in the same vein that Anthony Perkins couldn't escape Norman Bates...but what a legendary performance.

______________________________________

#32 - Jane Fonda, Klute (1971)


There was a small span from the late 60s/early 70s where it seemed like Jane Fonda was going to escape the bombshell/Barbarella era of her career and become an acclaimed and prestige actress.

With the release of Klute, she gave us what may be the best performance of her career.

And right after winning the Oscar, she became "Hanoi Jane" and she was "cancelled".

Why cancelled? She was photographed seated on a North Vietnamese anti-aircraft gun and the result was seen as a betrayal to many Americans. Her career stalled and between the span of 1972-1976, she only made appearances in documentaries and in Jean-Luc Godard's Tout Va Bien. It wasn't until 1977 that she made a big comeback in Fun with Dick & Jane and Julia...along with simply a few years of reevaluation after the failure of the Vietnam War and also the disgraced administration of Nixon. 

As Johnny Carson put it before she got interviewed on The Tonight Show, "she was right". 

Fonda is an actress that I admittedly respect her political ideals more than I do a lot of her performances, but when she does manage to settle into a role, she can do wonders with it.

Her Bree is a truly compelling creation, and Klute stands out as one of the best films of 1971 as well.

_________________________________________

#31 - Frances McDormand, Fargo (1996)

For her 1st win (already discussed the third and we still have the 2nd win coming), I think McDormand achieving a victory for Fargo is one of the more inspired wins in Oscar history.

On one hand, even though Marge Gunderson is a major and pivotal character in Fargo, she almost feels like a supporting character in terms of screen time...which is even more baffling when you consider that her co-star William H. Macy was nominated for Supporting Actor and is arguably the real lead of the film.

The kind of thing happens all the time, so I will just let it go. It is a topic for another time.

Marge Gunderson is a perky and quirky sheriff of a small Minnesota town. She is happily married and approaching the due date of her first child. 

With a thick Minnesotan accent and truly charming screen presence, it is hard to avoid using a word like "iconic" when discussing this performance.

Considering the fact she beat very dramatic performances by the likes of Brenda Blethyn, Emily Watson, and Kristin Scott Thomas, I can't help but feel like this is a rare example where the Oscar voters embraced a quirky indie favorite at the expense of a more bombastic or dramatic performance.

Having said that, I am still not sure I would've voted for her in this lineup. Of the names I mentioned above, both Blethyn and Watson would battle it out for my vote. 

Strangely enough, much like McDormand, I think Kristin Scott Thomas was more Supporting than her winning co-star Juliette Binoche. It felt like Bincohe and Macy were more lead than McDormand and Thomas were. 

Nevertheless, I celebrate this win because it does feel truly unique.

_____________________________

#30 - Geraldine Page, The Trip to Bountiful (1985)

My introduction to Geraldine Page was her voiceover work as Madame Medusa in one of my favorite Disney movies of all time: The Rescuers.

As a kid, there were certain performers I had such a strong attraction to for their work that I would often ask my mother about them, and I can distinctly remember being very entranced by Page simpy due to her voice alone.

When I got older, I discovered her work in other films. In Woody Allen's Interiors, a movie which is in a constant battle from being pretentious and intriguing, Page's Eve is a neurotic mess that becomes so compelling to watch...and I am convinced that in a lesser actress' hands, that role would've been a colossal failure.

She was also splendid in films like Summer & Smoke and in lighter fare like Pete n' Tillie. 

Nowadays, we hear about actresses like Amy Adams who have yet to win an Oscar, but it took Geraldine Page until her 8th nomination to win.

Many film buffs will debate whether this Oscar was deserved, especially due to the fact she beat Whoopi Goldberg in her iconic debut role as Celie in The Color Purple.

I am torn. I don't care as much for The Color Purple, but Goldberg was splendid in it.

When it comes to Page, I can't say that The Trip to Bountiful is a remarkable movie, but I think she equally as splendid in other ways.

There is a scene closer to the end of the film when Page is at a bus depot and it looks as though her journey back to see her childhood home is about to be thwarted and she starts to cry.

When watching this scene for the first time, I immediately said "Okay, she deserved this".

I think Goldberg and Page were both worthy.

As for some snubbed contenders that year:

WHERE IN GOD'S NAME WAS CHER IN MASK?!?!

Also, a quick shoutout to Mia Farrow in The Purple Rose of Cairo and Norma Aleandro in The Official Story.

______________________________

#29 - Michelle Yeoh, Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022)

-

When Michelle Yeoh stepped onto the stage at the 95th Annual Academy Awards, I was thrilled...and the honest truth is that it might be one of the best examples of me being equally happy for someone even if I may have voted for one of their competitors.

In the grand scheme of things, I did prefer Cate Blanchett's performance in Tar. However, there is no denying how much passion and warmth and all-around badass energy Michelle Yeoh brought to the table.

As someone who has been a big fan and champion of Asian cinema for most of my life, I am also thrilled that we FINALLY have an Asian performer winning in Lead. 

Yeoh became only the second woman of color and first Asian woman to win a Lead Oscar...and it has been 21 years since Halle Berry stood on that same stage accepting the honor. It is crazy to think it took this long considering that since then, we've had Denzel Washington, Jamie Foxx, Forest Whitaker, and Will Smith all win in Lead Actor. 

This was a performance that managed to feel right in line with so many compassionate Best Actress winning roles...but it also felt so unique at the same time.

I might not have been as enamored with the film as many others were, but there is also a lot to admire about the film...and I think Yeoh is MAJOR driving force behind that. 

_______________________________________

#28 - Hilary Swank, Boys Don't Cry (1999)

The 72nd Annual Academy Awards were essentially viewed as the coronation ceremony for American Beauty. The amount of praise and adoration that movie received at the time still, to this day, feels as strong as any movie to have come out in my lifetime. What makes it all the more remarkable is how much that adoration has waned in recent years...and perhaps I am biased because I have never found that movie to be the masterpiece that many claimed it was.

I bring up American Beauty because going into that ceremony, many expected it would become the 4th film to sweep the Big 5 Oscars: Picture, Director, Screenplay, Actor, and Actress.

It got the first 4, but Annette Bening lost Actress to Hilary Swank for Boys Don't Cry.

At the time, this wasn't exactly an upset. It seemed very possible that it would occur, and looking back on it, the transformation angle fits squarely into the Oscar winner motif.

I actually feel Swank was the better choice and I also think Swank has never managed to find the kind of role to showcase this kind of talent again...and yes, I say that knowing full well that she won a second Oscar...and if you recall, I didn't exactly rank that win too high.

Boys Don't Cry is a brutal movie. It is not an easy watch. I recently made a comment about the movie Till and how I felt that maybe a movie dealing with a truly horrendous racial crime didn't need to be made. Did we also really need to see this trans man get brutally assaulted and murdered?

That is always going to be a major debate.

 You also have the fact that they cast a cis woman to play a trans male...but looking past that, I feel like the manner in which Swank committed to the part is truly commendable. 

I do want to acknowledge a major snub in this category though, because I still think that Reese Witherspoon was utter perfection in Election. 

Rhyme pun not intended.

______________________________

#27 - Liza Minnelli, Cabaret (1972)

This win by Liza Minnelli is a prime example of  how something can simultaneously be both well-deserved and a mixed bag all at once.

I think Cabaret as a movie also aptly fits a similar description, because it is truly its own beast compared to its source material.

Despite the darker edges of the film, it loses a lot of its luster compared to the Tony Award winning stage production that had opened on Broadway six years prior...particularly how it handled the subtext of the relationship between Minnelli's character Sally Bowles and her lover Cliff (Michael York)…not to mention the erasure of subplots involving Fraulein Schneider and Herr Schultz. 

So the film might be great in its own right, but it is also very different in terms of its final product. Within the world of the film, Minnelli shines and is truly wonderful.

However, a lot of the dramatic weight that is often brimming under this character is lost. This is especially apparent after you watch other interpretations by such actresses as Natasha Richardson, Jessie Buckley, or Amy Lennox. 

    As a song, the titular number sounds cheerful and reads as cheerful but in the stage show, it comes along at a crucial moment where Sally performs it but realizes that the life she thought she wanted was a shame and that she would rather abort the baby she is pregnant with and resume a life of "pills and liquor". 

In the movie, the song basically reads exactly as the lyrics suggest. Perhaps it is unfair, but this is what makes me feel like I can fully embrace the performance as my favorite of that year.

She may have been more supporting but I did adore the nominated work of Cicely Tyson in Sounder and also Liv Ullman in The Emigrants, one of the few times she made a mark in the US not making an Ingmar Bergman film.

___________________________________________

#26 - Brie Larson, Room (2015)


I finally watched Room a lot later than many, because it came out at a time when I was basically checked out of not just following movie award season but following movies in general.

I do find it to be a very good movie and one that was highly emotional, but perhaps it was slightly overhyped for me.

I do support this win for Larson...even if I might've been more inclined to vote for Cate Blanchett in Carol. This is a truly powerful performance and was a great breakthrough for her.

I also think it is truly shameful that young Jacob Tremblay didn't get nominated for his performance as he not only worked very well with Larson, but his work was in contention of being the best performance by a young child performer in a film ever. 

Thinking about Larson now makes me want to revisit the film...and to be honest, the more I thought about her, the more I moved her up the list. She was originally going to be in the 30s, but I shifted her up nearly 10 spots. Maybe she will keep inching up more after a second viewing.

______________________________________

    #25 - Patricia Neal, Hud (1963)


1963 was a relatively abysmal year for American cinema and the Oscars as a whole. 

It was also the year that the true British obsession began with the Best Picture selection of Tom Jones, one of the weakest winners possible. 

However, one of the best American films from 1963 was Hud, which contained great performances by Paul Newman and Melvyn Douglas. Then you get Patricia Neal...who could sort of be the Best Actress equivalent of Anthony Hopkins in The Silence of the Lambs.

Okay, that sounds like a ridiculous comparison, but just hear me out.

Much like Hopkins, Neal is not technically lead when it comes to screen time. She might be the only real female to have significant screentime in Hud (around 20-25 minutes), but it does feel more like a supporting performance.

Having said that, her competition wasn't exactly the strongest and much like Hopkins, she dominates the movie.

This is a great example of an actress making an impression with such little screen time, but a lot of what works so well about this performance is how "lived in" it is. 

Neal's Alma feels like such a living breathing real-life person, and the weary but sensual energy is palpable. Director Martin Ritt insisted she play this part and much like he would years later with Sally Field in Norma Rae, he was able to see what an actress would be capable of that many in Hollywood wouldn't have realized.

_______________________________________

#24 - Olivia de Havilland, The Heiress (1949)


It is nice to be able to talk about Olivia de Havilland again; one of the greatest actresses to come out of the old Hollywood system...and to think we only recently lost her at the age of 104.

I think that her work in The Heiress might be the best performance of her career, or at least closely tied with her work in The Snake Pit the year prior.

I think what works so well with her performance, aside from the fact that she was directed by William Wyler (one of the best of that era), is what she does with her character arc.

The film is such a blistering take on the suffocating hold of the patriarchy, and we watch this very shy and sweet woman gradually change with her arc throughout the movie.

She lacks confidence and as that does grow within her, her body language changes, her vocal pitch changes, she becomes stronger but also colder emotionally. 

When it comes to watching a character's emotional state change in a carefully modulated descent/ascent, I think this performance is a prime example of a "master class".

______________________________________

#23 - Natalie Portman, Black Swan (2010)

I actually sort of have a weird history with this win. 

Very few Oscar wins seemed as universally beloved or as supporting as this one...and I felt like I was in the smallest vocal minority possible for not being as wowed by Portman as the rest of the world.

Over time, my love for her and the film itself have grown considerably.

Simply put, Black Swan has aged very well and so has Portman's committed performance, which has one of the strongest final acts of any film/performance since the 2000s.

I am not sure I have much else to say about it. Due to its relative recency, I feel like many have written about it and analyzed it to the death. 

Go check out the film if you haven't, because it does represent some of the best work of both Portman and Aronofsky.

Also - shout out to Barbara Hershey and Winona Ryder who both gave truly wonderful performances in the film and deserved more attention than that of Mila Kunis, who got most of the nominations that year.

_______________________________________

#22 - Frances McDormand, Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri (2017)

FilmTwitter loves to debate over whether or not Sally Hawkins or Margot Robbie or Saoirse Ronan should've beaten Frances McDormand for this performance.

Frankly, I loved her in this movie and I also loved the movie itself, which did seem to polarize some people...certainly moreso than McDonagh's most recent outing as of this writing, The Banshees of Inisherin. 

Those three other actresses I mentioned about were all great in their films, but I am choosing to celebrate McDormand here. 

When Martin McDonagh wrote the film, he stated that this was a part meant for McDormand and that if she wouldn't do it, he would never have made the movie.

The part does seem tailor-made for her. It even allows her a couple of moments to go bigger as McDormand is usually an actress of subtlety. Even those big moments, like when the billboards are on fire and she screams at her son, it happens quickly but the effect of it is so powerful.

As is the case with McDonagh, his work is usually dark but dripping with wit. Considering this is a woman who is mourning the rape/death of her daughter and the fruitless search of finding the assailant(s), it is remarkable how much of that deadpan wit McDonagh incoporates into the film and how well McDormand navigates it. 

She also acts extremely well with her ensemble that includes the truly brilliant Sam Rockwell, who won a very deserved Oscar for his performance, Woody Harrelson, Lucas Hedges, and Peter Dinklage.

A truly dynamic and intriguing character and one of my favorite acting wins in recent years.

_______________________________________

#21 - Anne Bancroft, The Miracle Worker (1962)

Anne Bancroft is one of those actresses who is closely linked to one particular role these days and it seems like many forget the rest of her filmography. 

And no, this isn't the role. The role in question is Mrs. Robinson from The Graduate.

However, I do think Anne Sullivan in The Miracle Worker is probably her second most famous role.

Much like Judy Holliday winning over Bette Davis and Gloria Swanson, I think Bancroft's win here is a bit overshadowed by Bette Davis once again...except not so much with an additional nominee, but a person who was snubbed.

This was the year of the infamous Bette Davis/Joan Crawford battle for attention after they made Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?

As the story goes, and any true film fan should know it...or you know the gist of it if you watched Ryan Murphy's Feud...Joan Crawford was not nominated while Bette Davis was campaigning hard to become the first actress to win a 3rd Oscar. Crawford, sensing a chance to try to get exposure, asked the other Best Actress nominees if she could accept on their behalf. In the case of Bancroft and Geraldine Page, both were on Broadway and at the time, that was usually considered a sound reason to skip the awards.

As a side note, Crawford also snagged a chance to present Best Director just in case Bette Davis DID win...but Bancroft did and that gave Crawford a moment in borrowed sunlight.

At any rate though, even if I might've voted for Davis or perhaps Katharine Hepburn for Long Day's Journey Into Night, I do support this win for Bancoft.

The Miracle Worker is a good piece and I think it translated well to film...and it is obvious how well Bancroft worked with her co-star Patty Duke. Their commitment to the physicality of the roles was certainly worth praising, and it felt really bold and brash seeing that kind of energy on display in an American film from the early 60s...a time for American cinema that was, in the grand scheme, a rather meek and docile time.

I think this race was truly too close to call, but Bancroft deserved it regardless of who I might've voted for in the end.

__________________________________

FINAL THOUGHTS:

I am very happy that I am finally a lot closer to completing this project.

I truthfully didn't realize how hard it would be to try to rank these performances. I also didn't realize how many of them actually stand up on their own as very good work when for many years, I often thought to myself how so many of them weren't deserving to win awards.

That is always going to be the problem, though. Awards create an unfair precedent...as do rankings like this if I am being honest. In the grand scheme of things, a lot of these performances so far have been truly admirable efforts.

A lot of these actresses also have not gotten the kind of attention and respect they deserve, so I am happy to shine a spotlight on them...no matter how small of a spotlight I am able to provide.

I will see you next time for Volume 5, in which I will FINALLY be revealing my ranking for my 20 favorite winners.

For my previous rankings, please use the links below:

Volume 1 - #94 - 80

Volume 2 - #79-60

Volume 3 - #59-40

*Volume 5 - #20-1* (coming soon)

Monday, January 16, 2023

My Quick Review of Chinonye Chukwu's TILL - Starring Danielle Deadwyler

 

"They're lucky that black people are looking for equality and not revenge".

-Kimberly Latrice Jones, following the uproar/protests due to the murder of George Floyd in 2020

When I think back a lot on my life, I think a lot about how I have responded to the idea of "revenge" towards people who deserve it. 

Even to this day, despite having grown out of the conservative upbringing I had and embracing a leftist (or should I say, "woke") ideology, I still have a very strong attachment to the idea of bad people getting the comeuppance they deserve.

When I think of the story of Emmett Till, one of the most infuriating and despicable aspects is that the two men who abducted and murdered him, Roy Bryant and J.W. Milam, were acquitted. That isn't to say that it was unexpected...it was the south in the 1950s... all-white jury. Of course, they were going to let them go free.

In 1992, Till's mother Mamie had the opportunity to listen to Roy Bryant speak about his involvement in her son's lynching to which he said "Emmett Till is dead. I don't know why he can't just stay dead" and further elaborated that the whole situation ruined his life. 

Bryant died of cancer in 1994, while Milam had died of natural causes in 1980. 

In case you aren't aware, Bryant and Milam murdered Till because the wife of Bryant, Carolyn (who is still alive by the way as of this writing approaching 90 years of age). She claimed that Till whistled at her and was trying to sexualize her. 

There is often a debate over the morality of fighting violence with violence...and perhaps this makes me a bad leftist, but I am left truly appalled by the fact that these two men faced no serious repercussions for what they did prior to their deaths.

They both deserved a miserable life...and I sincerely hope they all suffered in their illnesses. As for Carolyn Bryant, she also deserves a special place in hell and I do feel shame that a Grand Jury did not further proceed with an indictment last August. 

The story of Emmett Till is one of many, many, many, many grave injustices that have occurred in this country towards the African American community. Everyone should know this story, everyone should learn more about the life of Mamie Till-Mobley, everyone should see the pictures of Emmett Till's body just as his mother wished for the country to do.

I hate our country in many ways...and the sad truth is so much of what is infuriating about this actual event is still highly relevant in today's society. 

So, having said that, is making a movie about this story coming perilously close to being exploitative?

Is making a movie like this similar to that of making a mini-series about Jeffrey Dahmer or a movie focused on the horrors of the Holocaust?

I do have my own opinions about the Dahmer miniseries (which, ugh...typical Ryan Murphy schlock...), but Till is a movie that I think is highly important, but it also walks a very precarious tight rope. 

Not all movies need to be feel-good experiences, so I do appreciate that a movie such as this does exist.

However, I found Till to be a movie that did dive into making you feel disturbed and upset about the act, but it also tried so hard to be a movie that wanted to be very polished and uplifting by the end...and for this to be a very Hollywoodized movie was a WRONG choice.

Who exactly is this movie for?

Do we really think that any racist white person sitting in the south...or anywhere...is going to sit down and watch this movie and, better yet, suddenly change their minds?

A movie like Till, despite the great efforts of Mamie Till-Mobley as an activist following these events, should not make you feel uplifted at the end. 

The film ends with an intertitle celebrating the Emmett Till Anti-Lynching Act, which only recently got passed by Congress. 

Obviously, yes...it is great that such a bill exists...but should we really be celebrating that it took nearly 70 years after the events of the film for this bill to be passed?

Writer/Director Chinonye Chukwu did state in an interview that she really didn't want to "re-traumatize" audiences but wanted to take them on an emotional journey through Mamie and had hoped to show the "joy and love at the root of the narrative.".

Despite her intentions seeming sincere, I just don't think I can fully get behind this movie as a source of entertainment. I can fully understand why many in the African American community are opposed to seeing it because it just feels like it is digging up the turmoil that didn't need to be dug up. If anything, I am not even sure you could say this was buried to begin with...we are STILL dealing with these kinds of horrendous stories to this day.

The movie was successful at making me feel uncomfortable in the moments where it needed to, but I also felt uncomfortable in the uplifting shifts it took as it progressed...and that in turn made me feel even more uncomfortable.

Imagine if they made a movie about the murder of Matthew Shepard where we really dug into the night of its occurrence (even if we don't see Till's murder occur onscreen, just from a distance with some of the sound). Shepard's death was because he was gay...and for anyone who is reading this who identifies as LGBTQ+, can you honestly say you'd want to see THAT as a movie?

Sure, we have The Laramie Project but that focused a lot on the aftermath...and yes, so does Till but I think even The Laramie Project, despite its importance, also walked a similar precarious tightrope. 

There you have it. I think the film is rather erratic in how it presents itself, and I question if we truly needed to see the bulk of its subject matter depicted.

Through it all, however, is Danielle Deadwyler.

If there is any reason for you to see this movie, it is her performance.

The story of Emmett Till needs to be known, but I am not sure it needed to be in this manner. Deadwyler manages to hold a lot of it together due to immense commitment to the dark emotions she needs to convey. 

I think it is a crime that she is not more seriously in the awards discussion, but I think a lot of that falls on the content of the film itself...and there is the Catch-22. 

I do have issues with the film, but there is no denying the truly magnificent and emotionally charged performance of Danielle Deadwyler. 

She truly elevated the film, no question.

RATING: ***



SO...I Am Officially a YouTuber! (AND A POSSIBLE FAREWELL TO THE BLOG)

It has been a long time coming, but I have finally started the YouTube channel I kept wanting to create for the last several years! The chan...